The Precanon
DocumentsHistorical Documents

Arius and the Emergence of the Christological Debates in Alexandria[1]

Historical source

David Miano — La Jolla, California

Based on David Miano's study; the wording has been lightly adapted for readability. His argument, structure, sources, and citations are preserved unchanged. Quotations from ancient writers are given in published translations, named in the notes.

We acknowledge One God, alone Ingenerate, alone Everlasting, alone Unbegun, alone True, alone having Immortality, alone Wise, alone Good, alone Sovereign.

— Arius and his fellow clergy to Alexander of Alexandria, about 320 (trans. Newman, rev. Robertson)

Its importance lies in showing that resistance to Trinitarian formulation arose inside Christian debate itself, not only from outside critics.

According to tradition, the first person to bring Christianity to Alexandria was John Mark, a companion of Paul on one of his missionary journeys (Eusebius II, 16). Firm evidence of Christian communities in the city, however, appears only in the second century.

The number of these communities stayed fairly small until the fourth century. Their intellectual influence, though, shouldn't be underestimated. Alexandria was one of the great cities of the Mediterranean world, home to many cultural and religious traditions, and it was famous for philosophical inquiry well before Christianity arrived. Little wonder that Christian institutions also took root in this fertile intellectual environment.

Several prominent Christian thinkers who lived in Alexandria, among them Clement and Origen, openly called themselves students of philosophy. Their allegorical way of reading Scripture (finding layers of symbolic meaning beneath the surface) opened a deep rift with the Christian teachers of Antioch, who argued for a more literal reading of the sacred texts.

By the fourth century, many different ideas were in circulation about the nature of Jesus's relationship to God. Some theologians were hasty in spelling out their views on the divine nature of the Son, and sharp conflicts followed. Expressions found in Scripture referring to Jesus — such as Son of God, Christ, and Image of God — were widely used, and they were general enough not to provoke controversy on their own.

Even the meaning of the term God (theos) within Christianity remained contested. Some took it to mean the Almighty; others read it more broadly, as a powerful spirit or divine being. (Greek, after all, has no indefinite article to separate God from a god, just as capital letters do the job only imperfectly in English.)

Over the following years, this ambiguous theological language didn't cause an outright split. It did something quieter: it let different understandings of Christianity grow and harden across the Church. Extreme positions existed at both poles, but the radical groups holding them were too marginal to affect the broader chances of reconciliation. Meanwhile, Greek philosophy — especially strong in Alexandria — kept stirring theological inquiry among the educated classes and a growing circle of Christian teachers. The result was a flood of new ideas about, among other things, the origin and divine status of Jesus (Orthodoxy 147-150).

In time, positions emerged that looked very different from the earliest formulations. Those who held these new interpretations said their views faithfully reflected the teaching of the Apostles. Before long, the whole Christian world was caught up in the controversy (Life of Constantine II, 61-2).

At the very center of the fight stood two former associates: Arius and Alexander. Alexander held the office of bishop — the chief church administrator — of the city of Alexandria. The Christians of Alexandria held his position in such reverence that the title pope was being applied to Alexander even before the Bishop of Rome took up that distinction (Williams 42).

Arius, for his part, served as the presiding priest of the Baucalis congregation in the city. According to Epiphanius, he was unusually tall, wore a short cloak and priestly vestment, and had an agreeable way of speaking (LXIX, 3:1). Although his exact age during the period of the controversies is unknown, he is generally estimated to have been an elderly man (Epiphanius CLIV, 12).

The date traditionally assigned to the beginning of this debate is 318 AD. Ancient historians cite Athanasius's Letter to the Bishops of Egypt, where he says that thirty-six years had passed since the Arians were declared heretical. Their chronologies rest on the assumption that this letter was written in 356 AD. Counting back thirty-six years gives 321 AD as the date of the heresy declaration.

Modern scholarship has shown, however, that Athanasius's letter was in fact written not in 356 but in 361 AD. So the only council that can serve as a reliable chronological reference for the condemnation of Arius and his followers is the Council of Nicaea, convened in 325 AD.

The Declaration of Arius

At this point, it came to Alexander's attention that Arius was spreading a doctrine that other priests regarded as wrong. At the same time, some men in positions of church authority declared their agreement with it (Epiphanius LXIX, 3:5). Alexander promptly summoned Arius and questioned him on the matter. Arius laid out his position and offered a sustained defense of his views (Epiphanius LXIX, 3:5,6).

Alexander, using his authority as bishop, first asked the two sides to set out their beliefs in formal written declarations. The following is the letter of confession submitted by Arius and those who shared his convictions:

To Our Blessed Pope and Bishop, Alexander, the Presbyters and Deacons send health in the Lord.

Our faith from our forefathers, which also we have learned from thee, Blessed Pope, is this:—We acknowledge One God, alone Ingenerate, alone Everlasting, alone Unbegun, alone True, alone having Immortality, alone Wise, alone Good, alone Sovereign; Judge, Governor, and Providence of all, unalterable and unchangeable, just and good, God of Law and Prophets and New Testament; who begat [brought into being] an Only-begotten [only, one of a kind] Son before eternal times, through whom He has made both the ages and the universe; and begat Him, not in semblance, but in truth; and that He made Him subsist at His own will, unalterable and unchangeable; perfect creature of God, but not as one of the creatures; offspring, but not as one of things begotten; nor as Valentinus pronounced that the offspring of the Father was an issue; nor as Manichæus taught that the offspring was a portion of the Father, one in essence; or as Sabellius, dividing the Monad, speaks of a Son-and-Father; nor as Hieracas, of one torch from another, or as a lamp divided into two; nor that He who was before, was afterwards generated or new-created into a Son, as thou too thyself, Blessed Pope, in the midst of the Church and in session hast often condemned; but, as we say, at the will of God, created before times and before ages, and gaining life and being from the Father, who gave subsistence to His glories together with Him. For the Father did not, in giving to Him the inheritance of all things, deprive Himself of what He has ingenerately in Himself; for He is the Fountain of all things.

Thus there are Three Subsistences. And God, being the cause of all things, is Unbegun and altogether Sole, but the Son being begotten apart from time by the Father, and being created and founded before ages, was not before His generation [before He was brought into being], but being begotten apart from time before all things, alone was made to subsist by the Father. For He is not eternal or co-eternal or co-unoriginate with the Father, nor has He His being together with the Father, as some speak of relations, introducing two ingenerate beginnings, but God is before all things as being Monad and Beginning of all. Wherefore also He is before the Son; as we have learned also from thy preaching in the midst of the Church.

So far then as from God He has being, and glories, and life, and all things are delivered unto Him, in such sense is God His origin. For He is above Him, as being His God and before Him. But if the terms ‘from Him,’ and ‘from the womb,’ and ‘I came forth from the Father, and I am come’ (Rom. xi. 36; Ps. cx. 3; John xvi. 28), be understood by some to mean as if a part of Him, one in essence or as an issue, then the Father is according to them compounded and divisible and alterable and material, and, as far as their belief goes, has the circumstances of a body, Who is the Incorporeal God.

Epiphanius's copy adds a farewell, a prayer that the bishop may be well in the Lord, and the signatures. Six presbyters sign: Arius, Aeithales, Achillas, Carpones, Sarmatas and a second Arius. Six deacons follow: Euzoius, Lucius, Julius, Menas, Helladius and Gaius. Three bishops close the list: Secundus of Pentapolis, Theonas of Libya and Pistus.

(Athanasius, De Synodis §16, trans. Newman, rev. Robertson; farewell and signatures from Epiphanius LXIX, 8:5)

The Aftermath

At the assembly of Alexandria's priests, Alexander didn't ban any teaching that ran against accepted Orthodoxy. Instead, he allowed an open debate. To be fair, a universally accepted Orthodoxy was itself still taking shape at the time. Colm Luibheid makes the point. When the dispute with the Arians began, no agreement had yet been reached on how Father, Son and Holy Spirit are related, or on the divinity and humanity of Jesus. Some of the most basic questions were only then starting to be asked, and they would occupy the whole Christian world in the years that followed (Luibheid 3).

Sozomen backs up this account. Alexander, he writes, deemed it more advisable to leave each party to the free discussion of doubtful topics, so that by persuasion rather than by force, they might cease from contention (I, 15).

The assembly, though, didn't end the way Alexander had hoped. As Sozomen continues:

But it happened on this occasion, as is generally the case in a strife of words, that each party claimed the victory… The council was convened a second time, and the same points contested, but they came to no agreement amongst themselves. During the debate, Alexander seemed to incline first to one party and then to the other; finally, however, he declared himself in favor of those who affirmed that the Son was consubstantial and co-eternal with the Father, and he commanded Arius to receive this doctrine, and to reject his former opinions. Arius, however, would not be persuaded to compliance, and many of the bishops and clergy considered his statement of doctrine to be correct.

(I, 15)

Strikingly, Arius's supporters won more than vocal backing. A considerable number of bishops — most notably Eusebius Pamphilus, Bishop of Caesarea — openly declared their agreement with Arius. Letters urging Alexander to reconsider began arriving in large numbers.

Alexander didn't take kindly to having his authority challenged. His hostility towards Arius steadily deepened, and in a formal session he finally resolved to excommunicate (formally expel from the Church) Arius and his followers, and to banish Arius from Alexandria.

Meanwhile, the Roman Emperor Constantine had defeated his rival Licinius in September 324 and taken control of the empire's eastern provinces, and he was on his way to pay his first imperial visit to Alexandria. By the time Constantine's letter — his appeal to Alexander and Arius to settle the dispute, carried to Alexandria by Bishop Hosius of Cordova (Life of Constantine II, 64–72) — reached the city, the excommunication of Arius and his supporters had already been pronounced, and Arius had left for Caesarea to join forces with Eusebius (Epiphanius LXIX, 4:1). This marks the start of the second phase of the controversy.

A ninth-century canon-law manuscript image depicting the Emperor Constantine presiding over the condemnation of the Arians and the burning of Arian books.
A ninth-century canon-law manuscript image depicting Constantine, the condemnation of the Arians, and the burning of Arian books. Source: Wikimedia Commons, Constantine burning Arian books, from MS CLXV, Biblioteca Capitolare, Vercelli; public-domain manuscript image.

Notes

[1] David Miano, "Arius and the Emergence of the Christological Debates in Alexandria," La Jolla, California. Primary sources: Athanasius, De Synodis §16; Epiphanius, Panarion LXIX; Sozomen, Ecclesiastical History I, 15; Eusebius Pamphilus, Ecclesiastical History II, 16. The letter of Arius and his fellow clergy is preserved in Athanasius's De Synodis 16 and in Epiphanius's Panarion LXIX, 7:2–8:5. It is quoted here in the translation of John Henry Newman as revised by Archibald Robertson (Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, second series, vol. 4, 1892, p. 458). The farewell and the signatures stand only in Epiphanius's copy. Sozomen is quoted from the same series, vol. 2 (1890). The sentence from Arius's letter to Eusebius of Nicomedia is quoted in the translation of Glen Thompson (Fourth Century Christianity, Urk. 1).

Textual reference controls

The letter is quoted from a published translation and can be checked against the Greek. The same core text is preserved through Athanasius and Epiphanius and is catalogued in modern source collections as Dok. 1 / Urk. 6 / CPG 2026. Alexander's letters are deliberately kept in the reference layer as counter-witnesses, because they show how the opposing side framed Arius' teaching.

Bibliography

Ancient Works Cited

Athanasius. De Synodis in Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers IV; trans. A. Robertson, pp. 448-480, 1891.

Epiphanius. Panarion. trans. F. Williams; Leiden: E.J. Brill, 1994.

Eusebius Pamphilus. Ecclesiastical History in Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers I; trans. A.C. McGiffert, pp. 81-387, 1890.

Sozomen. Ecclesiastical History. London: Samuel Bagster and Sons, 1846.

Theodoret. Ecclesiastical History. London: Samuel Bagster and Sons, 1843.

Modern Works Cited

Barnes, Timothy. Constantine and Eusebius. Cambridge: Harvard UP, 1981.

Hanson, R.P.C. The Search for the Christian Doctrine of God. Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1988.

Luibheid, Colm. The Council of Nicaea. Galway: Galway UP, 1982.

Williams, Rowan. Arius: Heresy and Tradition. London: Darton, Longman and Todd, 1987.